Kellogg’s Explains Why Frosted Pop-Tarts Have Less Calories Than Unfrosted

You’d think a frosted Pop-Tart would have more calories than an unfrosted one. It seems logical, but that’s not the case.

Even with the addition of frosting to the Strawberry Pop-Tart, regular Pop-Tarts have 10 more calories.

As you can see below, the frosted Strawberry Pop-Tart has 200 calories, while the unfrosted has 210 calories:

poptart

It’s been a documented mystery ever since Spencer Gaffney wrote about it way back in 2009.

Well, Kellogg’s finally ‘fessed up and told Quartz that this nutritional conundrum is caused by a slightly thicker crust on to make up for the lack of frosting.

If you look on the Pop-Tarts site, there is not a single frosted flavor that has more calories than the unfrosted Strawberry Pop-Tart.

While it’s annoying, at least you know the truth now.

More content

Products
Snoop Dogg Will Pay You $10K A Month To Taste Ice Cream
Finding out that Snoop Dogg has a family-owned ice cream company and is currently looking for an official ice cream taste tester was not on…
,
Culture
Craig Robinson Reveals Just How Much Food Actors Get On TV Sets
Craig Robinson is someone you know, even if you weren’t paying attention to his memorably hilarious and zany characters in classic shows like The Office…
,
Products
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Is Getting A ‘Swicy’ Chamoy Makeover
This might be the most unexpected fusion-ha! of 2026. Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Chamoy Mega, the #1 chamoy brand in the U.S. and Mexico, are…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox