Milk Bar is Serving Up a 10 INCH Peaches and Cream Cookie Cake

Milk Bar, the NYC bakery famous for their wild creations like cereal milk soft serve, is serving up a new version of their Compost Cookie Pie. This time, they’re giving it a southern spin, with the new Peaches & Cream Cookie Pie. 

For the uninitiated, the Compost Cookie Pie is, as the name suggests, a giant cookie packed with an assortment of ingredients, from potato chips to coffee. 

The new one’s ingredients are a bit more subdued, but equally as delicious. Layers of white chocolate chips, dried peach bits, and milk crumbs are incorporated into to a 10-inch wide sugar cookie which is then drizzled with a peach jam and more white chocolate.  

Peaches? Check. 

Cream? Check. 

A cookie double the size of your head? Check.

Unfortunately, this is just a test item for the time being. Milk Bar will only be selling this for a limited time. If you want to try this diabolically sweet creation, it’s available for order online at www.milkbarstore.com until August 19th. 

More content

Eating Out
Jack In The Box Rolls Out Matcha For Its 75th Anniversary
Matcha keeps finding its way into fast food menus, and Jack in the Box just made it official. As part of its 2026 lineup, the…
,
Eating Out
Subway Is Giving Away Free Footlongs If You’re In the Middle Seat Of A Plane
Southwest Airlines recently announced it was ending its open seating policy, which means many of its travelers will be assigned a middle or “sandwich” seat.…
,
Culture
Guy Fieri Tried On A ‘Normal’ Look And The Internet Wasn’t Ready
Guy Fieri didn’t wake up one morning and decide to tone it down. The spiked hair, the flames, the sunglasses isn’t going anywhere. But for…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox