Chilling Reasons Why NOT to Use Reusable Bags

I just read a neat story on the Huffington Post that listed reasons why you should use a reusable bag when shopping for groceries. So, naturally, here are my reasons why not to use reusable bags when shopping for groceries.

Yes, it is trendy to use these bags, and you get to feel smug like people did when the Toyota Prius just came out, but while you are “saving the earth,” you might be damaging your health and indirectly hurting others as well.

The story in the Huff Post laid out its facts on the dangers of plastic bags, but if people will not even properly dispose of plastic bags, it is highly unlikely that they would give proper maintenance to their reusable bags.

The article states that it takes 15 to 1000 years for a plastic bag to decompose. Well, it takes a whole lot less time for the leftover bits of food in the reusable bag to decompose. At any given time, a bagger in a grocery story can open up one of those bags and unleash a vile smell within it. As the bagger holds his breath and tries to fill the bag with 90 little cans of cat food, he will likely be trying his best to work around the disgusting mold inside the bag.

A joint study conducted by the University of Arizona and Loma Linda University in California found that 97 percent of people interviewed said they never washed their reusable bags. Be honest with yourself reusable bag users, do you wash your bag?

So, do you want to know what’s growing in there? According to the study, it’s likely E. coli and other bacteria. They found that over half of the bags they studied had some form of bacteria growing in it.

Do you like leaving your bags in your car so that they are ready for you when you hit the market? Well the research found that there was E. coli in 25 percent of the bags collected from Los Angeles, the reason being was the warm weather. So while the bags sit in the hot trunk of your car, there could be a little something growing in there.

While you’re saving the earth from the horrors of plastic bags, most, if not all of these bags come from China, Bangladesh, or India. Do you know what that means? That means your bags are being imported, and unless it is being imported by an eco-friendly commercial vehicle, it is emitting greenhouse gasses for miles upon miles before these planet saving bags make their way to the U.S.

Let’s get down to the grimy specifics. If we break down some of the most popular bags used when grocery shopping you’d be surprised by its damage.

First off, jute bags and canvas bags are one of the most popular bags seen around grocery stores near you. Jute and canvas bags can affect you directly as the jute and cotton plants are usually grown with high levels of pesticides. So unless you know that your bag was made organically, it’s possible that there are still remnants of pesticides in the bag. Doesn’t that sound like a great place to put your celery and broccoli?

If that’s not bad enough, the Daily Star has an interesting article on how middlemen take advantage of the jute crop growers and sell the jute for double, leaving the farmers with little profit, if any.

At this point, not only are you supporting a possible health hazard, if you take a glance at the article linked above, you are likely supporting an injustice that can easily be a human rights issue.

So, where does that leave us? It feels like a lose-lose situation. Your local supermarket is pushing to save every penny it can (I mean, pushing to help save the planet) by eliminating a product that endangers our ecosystem, and is replacing it with something that could be equally harmful.

Even if you want to call “B.S.” on the importing issue, or the crop grower issue, doesn’t the lack of responsibility on our part, whether it is plastic or reusable, bother you at all?

How do we really know if we’re helping? I guess that is a Mega Million dollar question.

[Thx Paper vs. Plastic, American News Report and Earth Bags]



Isai has eaten food practically his whole life, so writing about food came naturally for him. Isai likes to find the lighter side of all stories. He is a man who believes in the simple things in life like string cheese, Cactus Cooler, and tagless t-shirts.

  • http://twitter.com/cameragrrl Wendy Whipple

    The main reason I DO use reusable bags is so that I am not overrun with plastic bags (which would end up in recycling, and cost money/resources to reprocess, etc. etc.). I don’t think I am acting out of a “lack of responsibility.” You seem to be implying that consumers, whether they are trying to go “green” or not, are an ignorant and malignant cause of the world’s ills. There is no good solution; we’re either evil for using the plastic bags, or evil for contributing to unfair trade practices. Frankly, I’m tired of the volatile language journalists (and bloggers) toss around, trying to stir the public into a frenzy… and accomplishing nothing. Rather than use inflammatory remarks, indicating that we should be “bothered” by our choices, give us real facts, honest and neutral pros and cons, and let us make our decisions from there.

    • isai rocha

      Thanks for the comment!

      Perhaps I could have been more specific with my closing statement. I didn’t necessarily mean that it is irresponsible to use reusable bags, I was leaning toward the side that we tend to use them irresponsibly by not properly caring for them.
      The purpose of this article was more about provoking thought than condemning those who use the bags. I posted a link to the “pro” side of reusable bags in case people were interested.

      However, this was an opinion piece, not so much a news article, so neutrality can be thrown out the window. I took a stance and supported it with points. The goal was not necessarily to get people to agree with it, the goal was to make people think and hopefully look into it more on their own.

      I love the passion, thanks again for the feedback!

  • Anonymous

    So buy a locally-made cloth bag (recycled cotton or hemp if that makes you feel better) and remember to wash it. That solves your bacteria problem, your pesticide problem, your shipping problem, and your attitude problem.

    I suppose it doesn’t help the jute farmers, but using plastic bags didn’t help them either, now did it?

    • isai rocha

      I can always count on your counter comments, Mr. Duck.

      Those are some good solutions, as is recycling plastic bags. The question is, will people care enough to do so? We can only hope.

      • Anonymous

        Reading my comment again, I realize how much of a dick I sound like; I apologize for that.

        That being said, as Maneneko pointed out, the post seems to go full negative. Even though it’s just “an opinion piece” it seems like you’ve passed up an opportunity to not just point out problems but also offer simple and effective solutions. While raising awareness of a problem is always a good thing, doing so in a quasi-alarmist manner is kind of questionable.

  • Maneneko

    Thank you for giving me info so that I can make better informed decisions.  This article does come across as pessimistic, however, offering no real solution.  I would have appreciated some possible alternatives or countermeasures.

    • isai rocha

      As always, appreciate the feedback! 

      They were kind of sneaky, but at the top of the story are a couple of links to previous stories about taking care of reusable bags. 

      If the bags are washed properly, then it’s not that big of a problem. But that “if” is a very big “IF” when it comes to these bags.

  • http://twitter.com/GarrettSteel Garrett Steel

    I used to always recycle my paper and plastic products, but after my city of San Jose forced me to either buy paper bags or use reusable (unless of course you are using food stamps… then they will give you the bag free of charge) and now I dump everything into the garbage. Cans, bottles, newspapers. I take great delight in telling the city to go screw itself for forcing its beliefs on everyone without so much as a vote. In addition, I now shop almost entirely at stores outside of the city where plastic bags are available and free. Sure hope those occasional dimes they are bringing in will offset the hundreds of dollars I now spend elsewhere.

    • Gallowaylong

      What an inspiration you are. Sad.

  • Gallowaylong

    I hope you weren’t paid for this article (or your editor)… lazy writing neither informs nor entertains…

    Another way to have written this article would have been to frame it as: How to Responsibly Use Reusable Shopping Bags.

    1) Advise folks wash their bags, then include (minus perhaps the holier-than-thou tone, but maybe that’s your schtick). Perhaps include a link to Dr. Bronners, or, more mainstream, 7th Generation or Method products (better yet, include a link to a recipe for natural homemade soap).
       http://www.drbronner.com/
       http://www.seventhgeneration.com/Natural-Laundry-Detergent?sub-cat=laundry-detergents
       http://methodhome.com/shop/dilutable-all-purpose-cleaner/

    2) After freaking out about China, perhaps include links to domestically made, fairly traded, responsible fabric bags from ethical companies. Or even how to make your own bag from old clothes, sheets, sails, etc…
     http://www.herobags.com/index.html
     http://www.reuseit.com/about-us/our-company/about-acme-bags
    http://www.ehow.com/how_6751876_homemade-cloth-bags.html

    4) If you’re going to make claims about jute (the pesticide claim is patently false,btw- your Earth Bags site in your “sources” shows as much…) and then refer to a link- include the link.
    Then, also include links to responsible producers of that and other sustainable materials.
       http://www.natural-environment.com/blog/2008/02/02/the-environmental-benefits-of-jute/
       http://www.greenchoices.org/green-living/clothes/more-sustainable-fabrics
       
     The Mega-Million Dollar question is really why did you write this article so poorly? And why was it accepted for publication? I’ve never read your work before, but this was pretty bad.

    • Gallowaylong

       *within area 1, after the parenthetical: “…then include the information about germs collecting within unwashed bags as a reason. Perhaps include a link…”

    • Anonymous

      Thank you for your comments. I felt the exact same way as I was reading the article. The response to “dirty” reusable bags is not to not use reusable bags. Although it is important to realize that not all “eco-actions” are completely positive, the arguments made in this article are weak and can be solved (as pointed out by Gallowaylong). 

    • isai rocha

      Yeesh. Harsh. Appreciate the feedback, though. For one, I did provide links to other stories on how to wash your bags in paragraph four.

      And you’re right, I could and probably should have added a link to domestic bag distributors. Here’s one that contacted me 
      http://www.hilexpoly.com/.
      I don’t remember off the top of my head what information from the Earth Bags site I used, but I did use something and wanted to credit them. I know went off this, and cited it, for the jute pesticide info.
      http://plasticvpaper.weebly.com/reusable—pros–cons.html  They could be wrong. I could not ask the jute workers themselves, seeing how they get robbed and can literally barely afford to live, I had no way of contacting them personally. I don’t think it was that horrible of an article. Its purpose was to provoke thought instead of mindlessly going with the crowd and using these bags, thinking everything is all hunky-dory. Yes, there are solutions to most of these problems, but you can find those anywhere. This article was a counter argument. That people counter back is awesome, it means at least someone is thinking, which was the purpose of the article.
      I hope you check out my other articles. As always, would appreciate the feedback. I hope by now my recent articles are deemed more than “poorly written.” If not, just let me know with more feed back.Thank you,Isai Rocha

  • Mr. Green

    Guys reuse your plastic grocery bags and save environment and also save some money, just check out the following website called 
    http://www.playantra.comThey are selling a small device called LOOP-A-CAN, which fits to your existing trash can and makes reuse of plastic grocery bag as trash liner a piece of cake, no tools or gluing needed, they are providing free shipping in continental US for limited time only…

  • OriginalGina

    Somewhat sucks for people living in cities like Long Beach, Ca. where you have to pay for paper bags or bring your own, so even more people are using reusable bags. 

  • Laura

    You do raise some valid points with your article. Would I sound like too much of a snob if I said that my reusable shopping bags are cloth and, therefore, easy to wash? I think you should consider adding “plastic” into your title as not all reusable shopping bags are plastic.

GET INVOLVED

STAFF

More in Opinion (9 of 10 articles)


Torani, you are a respected San Francisco based family-owned company that has produced flavoring syrups, sauces and blended drink bases ...